I Learn Torah And It's Geshmack

Subscribe

Just Learn the Gemara: Rav Mintz and Simplicity

Download the PDF sheet315 KB

I have several wonderful memories of Rav Mintz. He is a פשטן (one who seeks the plain meaning). He is not into complexity.

I would build up an elaborate פלפול (intricate analysis), a complicated argument that depended on several factors. Often I would compare seemingly dissimilar ideas, contrasting them. I have no idea what the סוגיא was, but I remember his expression. I spoke for maybe five minutes, going back and forth, building this idea. He looked at me like I had just shot him with a gun. “I have no idea what you are saying,” he said. “Let’s just learn the gemara.” A gemara I had already learned. But he sat with me, and we went through it, and that was that.

I try to channel that. Sometimes my favorite way to learn חומש is with nothing other than a חומש — what do the words say? No מדרשים, no complex סברא (reasoning), just the text. How does it actually make sense? Especially when learning רמב״ם, I’ve found the greatest ideas often live there — not in the layered סברא, but in what the words actually say. Simple is not dumb. פרד״ס all comes back to the root.

Thank you, Rav Mintz, for teaching me that sometimes the deepest thing is just to learn the words honestly. May we all be זוכה (merit) to find the אמת פשט (true simple meaning) in everything we learn.