I Learn Torah And It's Geshmack

Subscribe

Happy to Say Tzarich Iyun

Download the PDF sheet314 KB

I’m working on a ספר (book) on רמב״ם. I often give it to AI for analysis — to help with grammar, to summarize, and to see whether I conveyed my point. For some reason I asked it about the tone and nature of the work as a whole. It said the work wasn’t “too scholarly,” because it used terms like נראה לי, אפשר לומר, and צ״ע.

If that is the bar for being “scholarly,” I am happy to be in that camp. Rebbe Akiva Eiger ends many of his תשובות (responsa) with צ״ע, and even צע״ג. I believe the דרך (path) of many תלמידי חכמים (Torah scholars) is to seek out the truth and thirst for it. A true תלמיד חכם cannot be happy if the פשט (simple meaning) does not fit perfectly. But it is תורה; this is not science or mathematics.

This is learning the רצון השם יתברך (the will of Hashem). To say with one hundred percent certainty that something is אמת (truth), to be so strong with your assertions and your nuances — that is not something I ever saw from my רבנים. No, that is academia. Our approach is שפל (humble); it is measured, and with great humility.

Continues in “Both Glad and Sad to Be First”